SEC Staff Eases Path for Token Buybacks Once a Network Is Live
A fresh round of staff guidance from the SEC's Division of Corporation Finance says public buyback announcements on a functioning blockchain do not, by themselves, turn a token into a security under the Howey test.
Illustration · generated, not a photograph
Crypto projects have a clearer signal from U.S. securities regulators about when a token buyback announcement might trigger security status. In FAQs released Friday, the SEC's Division of Corporation Finance said that on a network that is already operational, a disclosed buyback program does not constitute a promise of "essential managerial efforts"—the element of the Supreme Court's Howey test that can turn a purchase into an investment contract.
The guidance draws a bright line between functional and pre-functional networks. For systems that are not yet live, staff said a buyback pitch could cross the line if the issuer frames it as a way to generate yield or returns for token holders.
The FAQs also address other post-launch promises. Staff said that after a network is functional, commitments to maintain, upgrade or grow the system would not satisfy Howey. Similarly, marketing the network's current uses or making broad, aspirational statements that stop short of touting profit would likely not qualify.
"The securities laws are starting to look opt-in now, at least as applied by the SEC to crypto," Gabriel Shapiro, a corporate securities attorney at MetaLeX Labs and former general counsel at Delphi Labs, wrote on X. "The buyback section goes further than I expected," he added.
In Shapiro's reading, teams can continue building, support token prices via buybacks and enjoy many of the perks of a public investment without providing shareholders rights. "They have opened a loophole in a regulatory regime whose whole point was supposed to be that you couldn't draft your way around economic reality," he wrote.
He also framed the move as part of a broader industry ambition: "get all the benefits of equity with none of the burdens."
The FAQs carry no legal force. They build on the SEC's March interpretive release and the proposed Regulation Crypto Assets, which would permit projects to sell tokens without full registration. The new guidance follows the agency's innovation exemption for tokenized stocks, introduced after the Clarity Act failed in the Senate, as Decrypt reported.
SEC Chair Paul Atkins indicated in July that the agency would step in if the legislation stalled, and the CFTC issued a similar warning in August, according to Decrypt.
Industry has largely embraced the regulatory route as its path forward, though Shapiro cautioned that rules are easier to unwind than laws. "A private plaintiff or a future SEC could have other ideas," he wrote.
Source reporting
The outlets whose reporting this account was written from.
Written from the reporting and primary documents credited at the foot of this story. Facts are credited to the outlet or document that established them. How Chainpress works
